The cable came out mid-write, and the volume showed as RAW
Someone caught the cable while the disk was mid-write. By morning Windows had exactly one suggestion: format it. The 4TB was imaged end to end before anything else was touched, and every repair after that went onto the copy — boot sector first, then the damaged copy of the MFT's first records. Not one byte was written back to the original. Fifteen years of client files came home with the folder tree intact.